{
  "generated": "2026-09-25",
  "headline": "Over 100x faster on PC, and faster on most other supported methods.",
  "methods": [
    {
      "method": "PC",
      "family": "constraint-based",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "linear_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release builds, 21 August 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.007574,
          "comparator_s": 0.09839,
          "ratio": 14.57,
          "andrey_shd": 12.0,
          "comparator_shd": 12.0,
          "empty_shd": 20.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.024,
          "comparator_s": 0.7529,
          "ratio": 31.03,
          "andrey_shd": 20.0,
          "comparator_shd": 20.0,
          "empty_shd": 50.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.06093,
          "comparator_s": 5.014,
          "ratio": 78.98,
          "andrey_shd": 54.0,
          "comparator_shd": 54.0,
          "empty_shd": 100.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.2213,
          "comparator_s": 50.8,
          "ratio": 218.54,
          "andrey_shd": 133.0,
          "comparator_shd": 133.0,
          "empty_shd": 200.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.8167,
          "comparator_s": 617.2,
          "ratio": 941.05,
          "andrey_shd": 357.0,
          "comparator_shd": 357.0,
          "empty_shd": 400.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "PC",
      "family": "constraint-based",
      "comparator": "gCastle",
      "regime": "linear_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release builds, 21 August 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.007574,
          "comparator_s": 0.09264,
          "ratio": 12.23,
          "andrey_shd": 12.0,
          "comparator_shd": 12.0,
          "empty_shd": 20.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.024,
          "comparator_s": 0.6774,
          "ratio": 28.58,
          "andrey_shd": 20.0,
          "comparator_shd": 31.0,
          "empty_shd": 50.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.06093,
          "comparator_s": 2.803,
          "ratio": 45.43,
          "andrey_shd": 54.0,
          "comparator_shd": 88.0,
          "empty_shd": 100.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.2213,
          "comparator_s": 16.22,
          "ratio": 69.89,
          "andrey_shd": 133.0,
          "comparator_shd": 256.0,
          "empty_shd": 200.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 2,
          "andrey_s": 0.8167,
          "comparator_s": 185.0,
          "ratio": 253.52,
          "andrey_shd": 357.0,
          "comparator_shd": 792.5,
          "empty_shd": 400.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "FCI",
      "family": "constraint-based",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "latent_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 9534 / AMD EPYC 7713, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release build, 15 September 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.06111,
          "comparator_s": 0.0376,
          "ratio": 0.62,
          "andrey_shd": 29.0,
          "comparator_shd": 29.0,
          "empty_shd": 48.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.08934,
          "comparator_s": 0.2915,
          "ratio": 3.38,
          "andrey_shd": 42.0,
          "comparator_shd": 40.0,
          "empty_shd": 96.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.1712,
          "comparator_s": 1.425,
          "ratio": 7.52,
          "andrey_shd": 135.0,
          "comparator_shd": 134.0,
          "empty_shd": 216.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.8598,
          "comparator_s": 12.32,
          "ratio": 16.49,
          "andrey_shd": 391.0,
          "comparator_shd": 391.0,
          "empty_shd": 492.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 3.564,
          "comparator_s": 31.54,
          "ratio": 9.56,
          "andrey_shd": 836.0,
          "comparator_shd": 836.0,
          "empty_shd": 884.0
        },
        {
          "d": 800,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 72.19,
          "comparator_s": 619.9,
          "ratio": 8.65,
          "andrey_shd": 2579.0,
          "comparator_shd": 2579.0,
          "empty_shd": 1772.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "GES",
      "family": "score-based",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "linear_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713, 128 cores",
      "build": "pre-release builds, 31 August 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.1542,
          "comparator_s": 0.4442,
          "ratio": 2.94,
          "andrey_shd": 13.0,
          "comparator_shd": 13.0,
          "empty_shd": 20.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 1.846,
          "comparator_s": 5.991,
          "ratio": 3.25,
          "andrey_shd": 47.0,
          "comparator_shd": 47.0,
          "empty_shd": 50.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 10.59,
          "comparator_s": 48.27,
          "ratio": 3.97,
          "andrey_shd": 88.0,
          "comparator_shd": 88.0,
          "empty_shd": 100.0
        },
        {
          "d": 150,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 39.94,
          "comparator_s": 170.9,
          "ratio": 4.28,
          "andrey_shd": 141.0,
          "comparator_shd": 141.0,
          "empty_shd": 150.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "BOSS",
      "family": "permutation",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "linear_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release builds, 31 August to 2 September 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.03134,
          "comparator_s": 0.09659,
          "ratio": 3.17,
          "andrey_shd": 3.0,
          "comparator_shd": 3.0,
          "empty_shd": 20.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.1737,
          "comparator_s": 1.023,
          "ratio": 5.7,
          "andrey_shd": 0.0,
          "comparator_shd": 0.0,
          "empty_shd": 50.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 1.315,
          "comparator_s": 6.735,
          "ratio": 4.86,
          "andrey_shd": 0.0,
          "comparator_shd": 0.0,
          "empty_shd": 100.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 6.733,
          "comparator_s": 37.06,
          "ratio": 5.62,
          "andrey_shd": 12.0,
          "comparator_shd": 13.0,
          "empty_shd": 200.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 39.01,
          "comparator_s": 162.9,
          "ratio": 4.31,
          "andrey_shd": 4.0,
          "comparator_shd": 12.0,
          "empty_shd": 400.0
        },
        {
          "d": 800,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 292.0,
          "comparator_s": 1017.0,
          "ratio": 3.42,
          "andrey_shd": 24.0,
          "comparator_shd": 58.0,
          "empty_shd": 800.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "GRaSP",
      "family": "permutation",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "linear_gauss_er",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release builds, 31 August to 1 September 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.03651,
          "comparator_s": 0.07059,
          "ratio": 2.06,
          "andrey_shd": 3.0,
          "comparator_shd": 3.0,
          "empty_shd": 20.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.417,
          "comparator_s": 0.771,
          "ratio": 1.79,
          "andrey_shd": 1.0,
          "comparator_shd": 1.0,
          "empty_shd": 50.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 2.834,
          "comparator_s": 4.385,
          "ratio": 1.55,
          "andrey_shd": 1.0,
          "comparator_shd": 1.0,
          "empty_shd": 100.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 40.08,
          "comparator_s": 55.87,
          "ratio": 1.39,
          "andrey_shd": 14.0,
          "comparator_shd": 14.0,
          "empty_shd": 200.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 1042.0,
          "comparator_s": 1166.0,
          "ratio": 1.42,
          "andrey_shd": 0.0,
          "comparator_shd": 1.0,
          "empty_shd": 400.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "DirectLiNGAM",
      "family": "functional",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "lingam_sf",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713 / AMD EPYC 9534, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release build, 15 September 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.1897,
          "comparator_s": 0.8204,
          "ratio": 4.34,
          "andrey_shd": 0.0,
          "comparator_shd": 0.0,
          "empty_shd": 19.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 2.693,
          "comparator_s": 14.25,
          "ratio": 5.28,
          "andrey_shd": 5.0,
          "comparator_shd": 5.0,
          "empty_shd": 49.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 8.421,
          "comparator_s": 57.78,
          "ratio": 6.87,
          "andrey_shd": 7.0,
          "comparator_shd": 7.0,
          "empty_shd": 99.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 545.4,
          "comparator_s": 1797.0,
          "ratio": 3.3,
          "andrey_shd": 13.0,
          "comparator_shd": 13.0,
          "empty_shd": 199.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "DirectLiNGAM",
      "family": "functional",
      "comparator": "lingam",
      "regime": "lingam_sf",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7413, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release build, 21 August 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.1318,
          "comparator_s": 0.7028,
          "ratio": 5.35,
          "andrey_shd": 0.67,
          "comparator_shd": 0.67,
          "empty_shd": 19.0
        },
        {
          "d": 30,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.4122,
          "comparator_s": 2.377,
          "ratio": 5.72,
          "andrey_shd": 5.0,
          "comparator_shd": 5.0,
          "empty_shd": 29.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 2.303,
          "comparator_s": 12.29,
          "ratio": 5.44,
          "andrey_shd": 5.0,
          "comparator_shd": 4.67,
          "empty_shd": 49.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 37.69,
          "comparator_s": 135.6,
          "ratio": 3.59,
          "andrey_shd": 6.67,
          "comparator_shd": 6.33,
          "empty_shd": 99.0
        },
        {
          "d": 200,
          "seeds": 2,
          "andrey_s": 481.9,
          "comparator_s": null,
          "ratio": null,
          "andrey_shd": 14.0,
          "comparator_shd": null,
          "empty_shd": 199.0
        },
        {
          "d": 300,
          "seeds": 1,
          "andrey_s": null,
          "comparator_s": null,
          "ratio": null,
          "andrey_shd": null,
          "comparator_shd": null,
          "empty_shd": 299.0
        },
        {
          "d": 400,
          "seeds": 1,
          "andrey_s": null,
          "comparator_s": null,
          "ratio": null,
          "andrey_shd": null,
          "comparator_shd": null,
          "empty_shd": 399.0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "method": "ICA-LiNGAM",
      "family": "functional",
      "comparator": "causal-learn",
      "regime": "lingam_sf",
      "hardware": "AMD EPYC 7713 / AMD EPYC 9534, 16 cores",
      "build": "pre-release build, 15 September 2026",
      "rows": [
        {
          "d": 20,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 0.4387,
          "comparator_s": 0.4363,
          "ratio": 0.99,
          "andrey_shd": 27.0,
          "comparator_shd": 27.0,
          "empty_shd": 19.0
        },
        {
          "d": 50,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 1.076,
          "comparator_s": 1.079,
          "ratio": 1.01,
          "andrey_shd": 62.0,
          "comparator_shd": 62.0,
          "empty_shd": 49.0
        },
        {
          "d": 100,
          "seeds": 3,
          "andrey_s": 15.78,
          "comparator_s": 15.53,
          "ratio": 0.98,
          "andrey_shd": 181.0,
          "comparator_shd": 181.0,
          "empty_shd": 99.0
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}